SUTTON HAULING INC
AUTHORIZEDUSDOT
1870662
MC Number
675849
Fleet Size
9
Total Drivers
8
Last updated: March 13, 2026
Safety overview
SUTTON HAULING INC is a small interstate motor carrier based in CLARENCE, New York, operating 9 power units with 8 drivers. Their safety profile raises flags: 4 of 5 BASIC categories exceed the 75th percentile, which is where FMCSA considers stepping in. Their driver out-of-service rate of 4.0% comes in under the 5.51% national average. No crashes on file. FMCSA records show 25 inspections for this carrier.
BASIC scores
SMS PercentilesHigher percentile = worse performance relative to peers. Scores at or above 75% may trigger an FMCSA investigation.
Out-of-service rates vs. national average
An out-of-service order means the driver or vehicle was pulled from operation during a roadside inspection.
For reference, the average driver OOS rate in New York is 13.2% and the average vehicle OOS rate is 25.6% across 122,475 carriers.
Company details
- Entity Type
- N/A
- Carrier Operation
- Interstate
- Operation Classification
- Authorized For Hire
- Cargo Carried
- N
- Hazmat
- No
- Safety Rating Date
- N/A
What are BASIC scores?
FMCSA tracks carrier performance through its Safety Measurement System (SMS), which scores carriers across six categories called BASICs. Each score is a percentile from 0 to 100, based on inspection and crash data from the past 24 months.
A score of 65 means the carrier performed worse than 65% of its peers. Anything above 75% can trigger FMCSA alerts or investigations. Brokers vetting new carriers should pay attention to scores above 50%.
- Unsafe driving
- Speeding, reckless driving, improper lane changes, seatbelt violations. All based on what officers find during roadside inspections.
- HOS / Fatigue
- Hours-of-service violations, logbook problems, driving past the allowed limits. Fatigued driving is one of the top causes of truck crashes in the US.
- Driver fitness
- Licensing problems, expired medical certificates, and other driver qualification issues.
- Controlled substances
- Drug and alcohol testing violations, possession, or impairment.
- Vehicle maintenance
- Brake problems, tire issues, lighting defects, load securement failures. Caught during the vehicle portion of roadside inspections.
- Crash indicator
- Based on crash history from state-reported data. Higher percentile means more crashes relative to the carrier's size and mileage.
Inspections
25
Total
63%
Driver %
Crash history
0
Total Crashes
Need trucking insurance?
Compare quotes from commercial truck insurers. Liability, cargo, physical damage coverage and more.
Get quotes (coming soon)Similar carriers in New York
Other carriers in the same state with a similar fleet size.
JBF EXPRESS INC
GROUNDHOG LANDSCAPING & LAWNCARE INC
JANET D SHAW
BLUE FLAME PROPANE INC
UNITECH SERVICES GROUP INC
Frequently asked questions
Is SUTTON HAULING INC authorized to operate?
Yes. SUTTON HAULING INC (USDOT #1870662) currently holds "AUTHORIZED" status with FMCSA. They're registered as an interstate carrier.
What is SUTTON HAULING INC's safety record?
SUTTON HAULING INC has 4 BASIC scores above the 75th percentile, which is where FMCSA may look into a carrier. Brokers should weigh these scores alongside the inspection history and crash data before making a decision.
How many trucks does SUTTON HAULING INC operate?
SUTTON HAULING INC operates 9 power units with 8 drivers on file. That makes them a small carrier.
Does SUTTON HAULING INC transport hazardous materials?
No. SUTTON HAULING INC does not have a hazardous materials flag in the FMCSA database.
Where is SUTTON HAULING INC located?
SUTTON HAULING INC is based in CLARENCE, New York at 9760 COUNTY ROAD, 14032. Phone: (716) 418-8340.
What are SUTTON HAULING INC's out-of-service rates?
SUTTON HAULING INC's driver out-of-service rate is 4.0%, compared to the national average of 5.51%. Below average, which is a good sign. Their vehicle out-of-service rate is 26.7% (national average: 20.72%). Above average, which may point to vehicle maintenance gaps.